Electric Water Heater vs Gas Water Heater Heaters Reviews, March 14, 2025March 14, 2025 When it comes to choosing a water heater for your home, the decision between an electric or gas model can be a tough one. Both options offer distinct advantages and drawbacks, depending on factors such as energy efficiency, installation costs, and hot water demand. Whether you’re looking for an affordable, low-maintenance option or a powerful system that can keep up with a busy household, understanding the differences between electric and gas water heaters is key. In this guide, we’ll explore the features, benefits, and downsides of both types, helping you make an informed choice based on your specific needs and preferences. Overview of Electric Water Heaters Definition and Basic Function Electric water heaters use electricity to heat water, typically through a heating element submerged in the tank or in a coil form. These units can be found in both traditional tank-style models and more modern tankless versions. The basic function remains the same: to provide hot water for domestic use, whether for showers, dishwashing, or other household needs. When the water temperature drops below a set threshold, the heating element activates, warming the water until it reaches the desired temperature. Types of Electric Water Heaters There are two main types of electric water heaters: tank and tankless. Tank Water Heaters: These are the most common type and have a large storage tank to hold hot water. Water is heated and stored in the tank until it’s needed, making these units ideal for households with high hot water demand. However, once the stored water is used up, it takes time for the heater to warm up more water. Tankless Water Heaters: Also known as on-demand heaters, these do not store hot water. Instead, they heat water as it passes through the unit. This allows for a continuous supply of hot water without the need for a storage tank. Tankless water heaters are compact, energy-efficient, and ideal for homes with lower hot water demand or limited space. Benefits of Electric Water Heaters Energy Efficiency: Electric water heaters are known for their energy efficiency, particularly in tankless models. They do not waste energy by constantly heating and reheating water, as in the case of tank-style heaters. In contrast, tankless electric heaters heat water only when needed, leading to potential savings on energy bills. Easier Installation: Compared to gas water heaters, electric units are easier and less expensive to install. They don’t require venting systems or gas lines, making them a good option for homes that lack these existing features. Many electric heaters can simply be plugged into an existing electrical outlet. Lower Upfront Costs: Electric water heaters are generally more affordable to purchase and install compared to gas models. The initial investment is usually lower, making them more accessible for homeowners on a budget. In addition, because there is no need for complex venting systems or specialized installation, labor costs are often lower as well. Disadvantages of Electric Water Heaters Higher Operational Costs: One of the main downsides of electric water heaters is their higher operational costs compared to gas models. Electricity is often more expensive than natural gas, meaning that an electric water heater may result in higher monthly utility bills. This is particularly true for homes with high water usage. Limited Hot Water Supply (Tank Models): Electric tank water heaters can be limited by their tank size, meaning once the hot water supply runs out, you’ll need to wait for the heater to warm more water. This can be inconvenient in larger households or during peak usage times, like when multiple people are taking showers. Longer Recovery Time (Tank Models): While gas water heaters tend to heat water faster, electric water heaters may have a slower recovery time, meaning it can take longer for the heater to refill and reheat the tank after use. This can be a disadvantage in situations where hot water demand is high. Considerations for Choosing Electric Water Heaters When deciding whether an electric water heater is right for your home, there are several factors to consider: Electricity Availability: Electric heaters are ideal in homes where electricity is readily available, and the local infrastructure supports it. In areas with unreliable power or frequent outages, electric water heaters may not be the best option. Space and Size: Electric tankless heaters are compact and suitable for homes with limited space, as they don’t require a large storage tank. They can be installed in small areas like closets or utility rooms, freeing up space in the home. Environmental Impact: Electric water heaters can be more environmentally friendly if the electricity used is generated from renewable sources, such as wind or solar power. However, if the electricity is sourced from fossil fuels, the environmental impact may be higher. Overview of Gas Water Heaters Definition and Basic Function Gas water heaters use natural gas or propane to heat water. The gas is burned in a combustion chamber, and the heat produced is transferred to the water through a heat exchanger. Like electric heaters, gas water heaters can come in both tank and tankless models, each offering distinct benefits depending on the household’s needs. Tank-style gas heaters store hot water in an insulated tank, while tankless models heat water on demand as it flows through the unit, eliminating the need for a storage tank. Types of Gas Water Heaters There are two main types of gas water heaters: tank and tankless. Tank Water Heaters: These are the traditional type of gas water heater and feature a large tank where water is heated and stored. Gas tank heaters are efficient at providing large volumes of hot water, making them ideal for larger households with high demand. However, like electric tank models, once the stored hot water is used, the tank will need time to refill and reheat. Tankless Water Heaters: Tankless gas water heaters heat water on demand as it passes through the unit, providing an endless supply of hot water. This feature makes them ideal for smaller households or homes with less consistent hot water demand. Tankless models also tend to be more compact, saving space in the home. Benefits of Gas Water Heaters Faster Heating Times: One of the primary advantages of gas water heaters is their faster heating times compared to electric units. Gas burners heat water more quickly, allowing the unit to recover faster and provide a continuous supply of hot water. This is particularly beneficial in households with multiple users or high hot water needs. Lower Operational Costs: In many areas, natural gas is less expensive than electricity, making gas water heaters more cost-effective in the long run. The lower cost of gas can help reduce utility bills, especially in homes with heavy hot water usage. Over time, this can lead to significant savings compared to electric water heaters, which typically have higher energy costs. More Reliable During Power Outages: Since gas water heaters don’t rely on electricity to operate, they can continue to function during power outages. This is particularly useful in regions where power outages are common, ensuring that you can still access hot water even when the electricity is down. Disadvantages of Gas Water Heaters Higher Upfront Costs: While gas water heaters can save money on operational costs over time, they tend to have higher initial costs compared to electric models. The purchase price and installation fees are generally higher because gas units require additional components like gas lines, venting systems, and specialized plumbing. Installation may also be more complex, requiring professional expertise. Venting Requirements: Gas water heaters require proper venting to expel combustion gases, such as carbon monoxide, safely. This means that homes need an existing venting system or the installation of a new one. The need for venting can make gas heaters less suitable for some homes, especially those without a dedicated venting system or those with limited space for installation. Maintenance Needs: Gas water heaters require more regular maintenance compared to electric units. For example, gas burners need to be cleaned, and the venting system should be inspected to ensure proper airflow and safety. If maintenance is neglected, it can lead to reduced efficiency, safety hazards, or even damage to the system. Considerations for Choosing Gas Water Heaters When considering whether to choose a gas water heater, it’s important to take several factors into account: Natural Gas Availability: Gas water heaters are most effective in areas where natural gas is readily available. If your home does not have access to a gas line, you may need to use propane, which can increase both the upfront and operational costs. Home Size and Hot Water Demand: Gas water heaters are particularly well-suited for larger households with high hot water demand. They can provide large volumes of hot water quickly, making them ideal for busy families or homes with multiple bathrooms. Tankless gas heaters are also a good option for homes with less consistent demand, as they provide on-demand hot water without the need for a storage tank. Environmental Impact: Gas water heaters emit carbon dioxide and other gases due to combustion, which contributes to greenhouse gas emissions. However, if your home uses renewable energy sources to power the gas system or if you combine the water heater with energy-efficient practices, the environmental impact can be mitigated. Space and Installation: Gas water heaters generally take up more space than electric models, especially in tank-style units. Tankless gas heaters are more compact and can be installed in smaller spaces, but they still require proper ventilation, which can limit placement options in some homes. Comparison of Key Features When deciding between an electric and a gas water heater, it’s essential to compare the key features that will impact your daily life, energy usage, and long-term costs. Energy Efficiency Energy efficiency is a significant factor when selecting a water heater, as it directly affects your utility bills. Electric Water Heaters: Electric water heaters are typically more energy-efficient in terms of how they convert energy into heat. Tankless electric water heaters, in particular, do not waste energy by continuously heating water; they only heat water when needed, making them ideal for smaller households or homes with intermittent hot water use. However, the downside is that electricity tends to be more expensive than natural gas, so despite the high efficiency of electric heaters, their operational costs can be higher over time. Gas Water Heaters: Gas heaters tend to be less energy-efficient than electric models because combustion processes are inherently less efficient than direct electrical heating. However, natural gas is often cheaper than electricity, so a gas heater can still be more cost-effective in terms of operational costs, especially in areas where natural gas prices are low. Gas heaters with higher efficiency ratings (such as condensing gas models) are available and can reduce energy loss, but they typically come at a higher price point. In general, electric heaters are more efficient in terms of converting energy into heat, but gas heaters may be cheaper to run due to the lower cost of natural gas compared to electricity. Installation and Maintenance Installation and maintenance are other critical factors to consider when choosing between an electric and a gas water heater. Electric Water Heaters: Electric heaters are easier and cheaper to install because they do not require gas lines, venting, or specialized connections. They can be plugged into an existing electrical outlet, and their installation is usually a straightforward process. As a result, the upfront installation cost is generally lower compared to gas heaters. Maintenance for electric heaters is also simpler, as they have fewer components that need regular servicing. However, it’s still important to inspect the heating elements and ensure the tank is free from sediment buildup to maintain optimal performance. Gas Water Heaters: Gas heaters require more complex installation due to the need for a gas line and a venting system to expel combustion gases. This additional complexity increases both the upfront installation cost and the labor required. Maintenance for gas water heaters is also more involved, as the gas burner needs periodic cleaning and the venting system must be checked to ensure safe operation. If maintenance is neglected, it can result in efficiency losses or safety risks, such as carbon monoxide buildup. Electric water heaters are less expensive and easier to install, while gas heaters involve more upfront investment in installation and require ongoing maintenance to ensure safe and efficient operation. Heating Speed and Hot Water Supply The speed at which a water heater provides hot water and its ability to meet the demand of a household are crucial aspects to consider. Electric Water Heaters: Electric tank heaters can take longer to heat water compared to gas models. The time it takes to refill and reheat the tank after hot water is used can be a limitation in larger households with high water demand. Electric tankless water heaters are more efficient in terms of providing continuous hot water, but they may still have limitations depending on the flow rate and power supply. For example, multiple simultaneous uses of hot water (e.g., running a shower and a dishwasher) could result in a reduced water temperature. Gas Water Heaters: Gas water heaters, especially tank models, typically have faster heating recovery times than their electric counterparts. The combustion process heats water much quicker, allowing a gas water heater to deliver hot water more efficiently. Tankless gas water heaters also provide an endless supply of hot water on demand and are better suited for larger households with multiple users. The ability of a gas tankless water heater to handle higher flow rates makes it a strong option for homes that experience frequent simultaneous hot water usage. Gas heaters generally outperform electric ones when it comes to delivering hot water quickly and efficiently, especially during high-demand periods. Environmental Impact The environmental impact of a water heater is an important consideration for those seeking eco-friendly solutions. Electric Water Heaters: The environmental impact of electric water heaters largely depends on how the electricity is generated. In areas where electricity is produced from renewable sources like wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, electric water heaters are a more environmentally friendly option. However, in regions that rely heavily on fossil fuels (like coal) for electricity generation, the environmental impact can be more significant. Overall, electric water heaters themselves have no emissions since they don’t involve combustion. Gas Water Heaters: Gas water heaters, on the other hand, burn fossil fuels to heat water, resulting in the emission of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases. While natural gas is cleaner than coal, it still contributes to environmental pollution and climate change. Gas heaters are less environmentally friendly compared to electric heaters unless they are paired with renewable energy sources, such as solar or wind power. Electric water heaters have a potentially lower environmental impact if powered by renewable energy, while gas heaters emit greenhouse gases through combustion. Longevity and Durability Durability and how long the water heater lasts before requiring replacement is an important consideration for any homeowner. Electric Water Heaters: Electric water heaters generally last longer than gas models. With proper maintenance, an electric tank model can last up to 15-20 years, while tankless electric models can last even longer. Tankless electric water heaters are typically more durable due to the absence of a storage tank that can suffer from corrosion. However, like all appliances, their lifespan depends on the quality of installation, water quality, and usage patterns. Gas Water Heaters: Gas water heaters, while generally reliable, have a slightly shorter lifespan compared to electric models. Tank models typically last between 10-15 years, while tankless models may last around 15-20 years. The wear and tear on the gas burner, the need for regular maintenance, and the potential for corrosion in the tank can reduce the lifespan of gas water heaters if not properly cared for. Electric water heaters tend to have a longer lifespan than gas models, particularly tankless versions, which have fewer components subject to wear and tear. Conclusion The choice between an electric and a gas water heater depends on several factors, including energy efficiency, installation and maintenance costs, heating speed, and long-term durability. Electric water heaters are generally more energy-efficient, easier to install, and require less maintenance, but they tend to have higher operational costs due to the higher price of electricity. Gas water heaters provide faster heating times and lower operational costs but come with higher installation expenses and maintenance requirements. Enjoyed this guide of electric water heater vs gas water heater? Then be sured to check out our other heaters reviews. Best Electric Tankless Water Heater Best Propane Tankless Water Heater Best Natural Gas Tankless Water Heater Best 7500-Watt Electric Garage Heater Best 10,000-Watt Electric Garage Heater Guides and Tips Heater